Introduction
In appellate proceedings, the question of whether a notice of appeal can be amended at any stage often arises. Two cases—Famese & Ors v. Kayode & Ors (2017) LPELR-43233(CA) and Ugochukwu & Ors v. Nwaduka & Anor (2024) LPELR-61822(CA)—provide clarity on this issue, affirming the court’s discretionary powers to allow amendments when they serve the ends of justice.
Can a Notice of Appeal Be Amended at Any Time?
Insights from Famese & Ors v. Kayode & Ors
Justice Obande Festus Ogbuanya, JCA, affirmed that:
“The fact that briefs of argument have been filed and exchanged and an appeal is virtually ready for hearing will not prevent the Court from exercising its undoubted discretion to allow an amendment… so long as the amendment would serve the ends of justice and fairness, and the other party can be compensated by cost.”
This emphasizes that:
1. Timing Is Not a Barrier: Amendments can be made even if the appeal is ready for hearing.
2. Justice and Fairness Prevail: The court prioritizes substantive justice over procedural technicalities.
3. Compensatory Costs: The opposing party may be awarded costs to mitigate any inconvenience caused by the amendment.
Insights from Ugochukwu & Ors v. Nwaduka & Anor
Justice Amina Audi Wambai, JCA, reinforced the principle under Order 7 Rule 8 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2021:
“A Notice of Appeal may be amended by or with the leave of the Court at any time.”
This confirms that the rules explicitly permit amendments to notices of appeal at any stage, provided the court grants leave.
Key Takeaways
1. Flexibility in Amendments
• Both cases highlight that amendments to notices of appeal are not restricted by time and can be made even at advanced stages of the appellate process.
2. Court’s Discretion
• The court retains broad discretion to determine whether an amendment serves justice and fairness.
3. No Room for Technicalities
• Procedural objections based solely on the timing of amendments are unlikely to succeed if the substantive rights of the parties are preserved.
4. Compensation for the Opposing Party
• To ensure fairness, courts often award costs to the opposing party when an amendment is allowed.
Practical Implications for Legal Practice
• Appellants: Always seek leave of the court when amending a notice of appeal. Prepare to justify how the amendment will advance justice.
• Respondents: Be prepared to argue against amendments only if they result in significant prejudice or unfairness. Otherwise, seek compensatory costs.
• Judges: Balance procedural compliance with the need to ensure justice and fairness in the appellate process.
Conclusion
Both Famese v. Kayode and Ugochukwu v. Nwaduka emphasize that amendments to notices of appeal are permissible at any time, provided they serve the ends of justice. This flexible approach ensures that technicalities do not override the court’s primary objective of delivering fair outcomes.
Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal issues, consult a qualified legal professional.
If you found this helpful, please share it on social media — it only takes a click.
Leave a Reply